Unconstitutional vaccine rights bills keep coming

Thursday, March 31, 2011 by: Alan Phillips, J.D.
Tags: vaccine exemptions, laws, health news

eTrust Pro Certified

Most Viewed Articles
Popular on Facebook
BACK INTO THE CLOSET: Why U.S. reporters are not allowed to write about rainbow events in nations where being gay is still condemned
Depopulation test run? 75% of children who received vaccines in Mexican town now dead or hospitalized
A family destroyed: Six-month-old dies after clinic injects baby with 13 vaccines at once without mother's informed consent
INVESTIGATION: Three days before Dr. Bradstreet was found dead in a river, U.S. govt. agents raided his research facility to seize a breakthrough cancer treatment called GcMAF
BAM! Chipotle goes 100% non-GMO; flatly rejecting the biotech industry and its toxic food ingredients
BOMBSHELL: China and America already at war: Tianjin explosion carried out by Pentagon space weapon in retaliation for Yuan currency devaluation... Military helicopters now patrolling Beijing
ECONOMIC SLAVERY FOR ALL: While we were distracted with the Confederate flag flap, Congress quietly forfeited our entire economic future via fast-track trade authority
March Against Monsanto explodes globally... World citizens stage massive protests across 38 countries, 428 cities... mainstream media pretends it never happened
GMO crops totally banned in Russia... powerful nation blocks Monsanto's agricultural imperialism and mass poisoning of the population
SCOTUS same-sex marriage decision may have just legalized the concealed carry of loaded firearms across all 50 states, nullifying gun laws everywhere
Nearly every mass shooting in the last 20 years shares one surprising thing? and it's not guns
Vicious attack on Dr. Oz actually waged by biotech mafia; plot to destroy Oz launched after episode on glyphosate toxicity went viral
Holistic cancer treatment pioneer Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez dies suddenly; patients mourn the loss of a compassionate, innovative doctor who helped thousands heal from cancer
Pepsi drops aspartame from diet soda as consumers reject toxic sweetener
Bride of Frankenfood: Hillary Clinton pushes GMO agenda... hires Monsanto lobbyist... takes huge dollars from Monsanto
STATINS RED ALERT: Widely prescribed drugs act as cellular poisons that accelerate aging... deactivate DNA repair... promote diabetes, muscle fatigue and memory loss
Wild eyes and bowl cuts: Why do mass shooters always share the same hair styles and crazed zombie stares?
Mind control through emotional domination: How we're all being manipulated by the "crisis of the NOW"
(NaturalNews) Recently, Washington State voted to pass SB 5005, a law making doctors the gatekeepers of all vaccine exemptions -- medical, religious and philosophical. This law was passed despite SB 5005's Constitutional failings (for a legal analysis of the bill, see Proposed new limits on vaccine exemptions: Are they Constitutional?) Washington citizens now have two choices: Challenge the law in court, or get their representatives to repeal SB5005, since it is unconstitutional.

The reality is, legislators can pass a law that whether it is Constitutional or not, and once passed, the new law is "good law" -- enforceable -- unless and until it is successfully challenged in court or repealed. If Washington State citizens pursue one of these courses successfully, legislators who voted for it will take a credibility hit, as they were informed about the Constitutionality problems in advance of the vote on the bill.

Meanwhile, the war rages on in other states. For example, New York's S00384/A00343 would allow health care practitioners to administer STD vaccines to minors without the consent or knowledge of their parents. This is unconstitutional on several grounds. For one, parents are legally presumed to act in their children's best interests, so unless a judge rules that a parent is unfit, bypassing parental consent would usurp the parents' Fourteenth Amendment due process right to parent their own children. This bill presumes that fit parents can't or won't make the right decision for their child, and would set a disturbing precedent if passed.

The New York bill is questionable on other grounds as well. Since minor's religious beliefs are deemed to be those of their parents for legal purposes, every time a health care practitioner vaccinates a minor whose parent has religious objections to vaccines, that parent's First Amendment "free exercise" rights will be violated, with that Constitutional violation sanctioned by the state. The bill also requires the minor to have the "capacity to consent" to the vaccine and to give their consent, but it doesn't define "capacity" or explain what constitutes "consent" for a minor. This makes a consistent application of the bill all but impossible, which means it may violate the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause. For a more detailed legal analysis of this bill, see NY Vaccine Bill Usurps Constitutional Rights.

Finally, despite criticism of New Jersey's ACR157 on Constitutional grounds in recent weeks, this "Assembly Concurrent Resolution" went on to become bill S2625 and A3836. It requires applicants for a religious exemption to immunizations to provide a written statement explaining how the vaccines conflict with the applicant's religious tenets and practices. However, federal courts have held that one need only have a belief that is religious in nature and sincerely held to qualify for a vaccine religious exemption, not a tenet or practice. In addition, the words 'tenet' and 'practice' clearly imply, if not outright require, membership in an organized religion. But federal courts have held that it doesn't matter whether or not you belong to an organized religious organization, nor which one you belong to if you do, so this bill violates both the free exercise and establishment clauses of the First Amendment. If enacted into law, S2625/A3836 will clearly be vulnerable to a formal challenge in court, and New Jersey residents should seek immediate repeal, as it is clearly an unconstitutional statute.

The race is on to limit vaccine exemption rights and to add new immunizations to the schedule around the country. If you are not in the states mentioned above, you have no reason to be complacent, because your state will be next! We must be vigilant, and we must become legislatively active. Rights in this arena are not stagnant. If we are not taking steps to expand them, we will become victims of their disappearance. I recommend joining the National Vaccine Information Center's Advocacy Portal. It's free to sign up, and you can track vaccine legislation in your state and act quickly and easily to support vaccine freedom of choice. If your state doesn't already have a director, volunteer! Our future depends on it.

About the author:
Alan Phillips, Vaccine Rights Attorney, 1-828-575-2622
Vaccine Rights (

Follow real-time breaking news headlines on
Vaccine exemptions at
Join over four million monthly readers. Your privacy is protected. Unsubscribe at any time.
comments powered by Disqus
Take Action: Support by linking back to this article from your website

Permalink to this article:

Embed article link: (copy HTML code below):

Reprinting this article:
Non-commercial use OK, cite with clickable link.

Follow Natural News on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest

Colloidal Silver

Advertise with NaturalNews...

Support NaturalNews Sponsors:

Advertise with NaturalNews...


Sign up for the FREE Natural News Email Newsletter

Receive breaking news on GMOs, vaccines, fluoride, radiation protection, natural cures, food safety alerts and interviews with the world's top experts on natural health and more.

Join over 7 million monthly readers of, the internet's No. 1 natural health news site. (Source:

Your email address *

Please enter the code you see above*

No Thanks

Already have it and love it!

Natural News supports and helps fund these organizations:

* Required. Once you click submit, we will send you an email asking you to confirm your free registration. Your privacy is assured and your information is kept confidential. You may unsubscribe at anytime.