Subscribe (free)
About NaturalNews
Contact Us
Write for NaturalNews
Media Info
Advertising Info

Obesity-mortality paradox debunked: Overweight type 2 diabetes patients do NOT survive better

Tuesday, January 21, 2014 by: Reuben Chow
Tags: obesity, mortality, paradox

Most Viewed Articles
Popular on Facebook
(NaturalNews) A recent study published in the New England Journal of Medicine has debunked the findings of some recent studies which suggested that diabetics who were overweight or obese could have lower mortality rates than their normal-weight counterparts.

The study, led by researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health, looked at 2,457 men who took part in the Health Professionals Follow-up Study (HPFS) and 8,970 women who took part in the Brigham and Women's Hospital-based Nurses' Health Study (NHS); the subjects were followed for 26 years and 36 years respectively.

The study found that there was a positive link between body mass index (BMI) measured at the point of diabetes diagnosis and the risk of death from all causes. Those who had normal weight had the lowest risk of death, while overweight or obese study subjects did not enjoy lower mortality rates.

"Obesity-mortality paradox" debunked

Obesity is a known risk factor for ailments such as diabetes, heart disease and cancer, and studies have revealed that obese people with these conditions have higher mortality rates. However, some recent studies have also suggested the opposite - that obesity has a beneficial effect and actually protects against death from all causes and death due to conditions such as heart failure, stroke and diabetes. This "obesity-mortality paradox" has raised a fair amount of controversy.

Those studies, though, have some limitations, according to the authors of the recent Harvard study. These include small sample sizes, measuring BMI years after diabetes was diagnosed, and, significantly, not accounting for weight loss from smoking and undiagnosed chronic diseases.

Smokers and chronically ill persons could be residing in the same "normal weight" study group as those who were lean and healthy. Because these persons have inherent risk factors, they would skew the relationship between weight and mortality, making the "normal weight" group seem worse off than they should be and the "overweight" group seem better off than they should be.

"After carefully controlling for many of these factors in our analysis, we observed that excess weight in those with diabetes was not advantageous for survival. These findings underscore the importance of addressing methodological biases in the analysis of BMI and mortality," said Deirdre Tobias, a research fellow in the Department of Nutrition at the Harvard School of Public Heath who led the study.

Limitations of BMI

There is another issue - BMI is not a precise enough indicator of body fat content. As pointed out by researchers from the Perelman School of Medicine, BMI does not account for factors like fat distribution, muscle to fat ratio, as well as the gender and ethnic differences when it comes to body composition - and these are major factors when it comes to health and mortality.

Some persons may have BMIs which suggest they are obese, but research has shown some of them may actually have improved metabolic profile and lower cardiovascular risk, while some persons with normal-range BMIs may actually be metabolically unhealthy


Going forward, it is clear that better measures of obesity and being overweight that can better predict disease and mortality risks need to be formulated. In the meantime, Frank Hu, professor of nutrition and epidemiology at the Harvard School of Public Health and a senior author of the recent study, summed up his team's findings: "These data dispel the notion that being overweight or obese confers survival advantage among diabetic patients. Clearly, weight management is an important therapeutic strategy for overweight or obese individuals with type 2 diabetes."

Sources for this article include:


Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania (2013, August 22). BMI not accurate enough: Obesity/mortality paradox demonstrates urgent need for more refined metabolic measures. ScienceDaily. Retrieved January 21, 2014, from http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/08/130822141948.htm

Northwestern University (2012, August 7). Thinner diabetics face higher death rate. ScienceDaily. Retrieved January 21, 2014, from http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/08/120807161033.htm


About the author:
Reuben Chow has a keen interest in natural health and healing as well as personal growth.

Subscribe to his natural health newsletter or follow his health websites on Facebook.

His main health websites Insights on Health and All 4 Natural Health focus on being healthy naturally, while his other health websites cover topics such as cancer, depression, holistic depression help, as well as omega 3 fatty acids. He also owns self improvement and inspirational websites like Inspiration 4 Living, allinspiration.com, Life Changing Quotes, and 101 Inspirational Ideas. Through his network of sites at The Journey of Life, he hopes to help improve people's lives.
STAY INFORMED! Free subscription to the Health Ranger's email newsletter
Get breaking news alerts on GMOs, fluoride, superfoods, natural cures and more...
Join over four million monthly readers. Your privacy is protected. Unsubscribe at any time.
comments powered by Disqus

Sign up for the FREE Natural News Email Newsletter

Receive breaking news on GMOs, vaccines, fluoride, radiation protection, natural cures, food safety alerts and interviews with the world's top experts on natural health and more.

Join over 7 million monthly readers of NaturalNews.com, the internet's No. 1 natural health news site. (Source: Alexa.com)

Your email address *

Please enter the code you see above*

No Thanks

Already have it and love it!

Natural News supports and helps fund these organizations:

* Required. Once you click submit, we will send you an email asking you to confirm your free registration. Your privacy is assured and your information is kept confidential. You may unsubscribe at anytime.