 |
FREE Natural Health Newsletter
Receive natural health product reviews, recommendations and alerts.
Instant download of 20+ free health reports and exclusive interviews.
Join over 1.2 million monthly readers.
|
 |
|
(NaturalNews) More than 30 percent of studies conducted on antidepressant drugs go unpublished, apparently because they fail to show that the drug works as advertised, according to a new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine.
In addition, published studies often interpret the data as more favorable toward the drug than it actually is.
"Not only were positive results more likely to be published, but studies that were not positive, in our opinion, were often published in a way that conveyed a positive outcome," the researchers wrote.
Although the FDA requires that pharmaceutical companies provide the results of all studies conducted on a new drug before it receives approval, there is no requirement that those studies be published where doctors, health researchers and the public can read them. A team of researchers from institutions including the Oregon Health and Science University, the Portland Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Kent State University and the University of California at Riverside compared the results of studies reported in the FDA database with whether and how those studies were reported in published literature.
"It tells you where they placed their bets before they saw the data," lead researcher Erick Turner said.
The researchers examined 74 studies conducted on 12 antidepressants between 1981 and 2004, involving a total of 12,564 patients. Only 38 of these studies (51 percent) produced favorable results for the drugs being tested. All but one of those studies - or 94 percent - were published.
In contrast, 22 of the 36 studies that failed to show favorable results (61 percent) went unpublished. Of the 14 studies published, only three interpreted the data unfavorably. The other 11 studies, in contrast with FDA interpretations of the same data, cast the drugs as more effective than they actually were.
For example, of the three studies conducted on Glaxo SmithKline's Wellbutrin, only the one showing positive results was published. Of five studies conducted on Pfizer's Zoloft, the one showing positive results was published; the one with questionable results was spun as if the drug were effective, and the three with unfavorable results were never published.
According to the researchers, the publication bias inflated the reported effectiveness of the anti-depressant drugs by an average of 32 percent. The actual amount varied from a low of 11 percent for Glaxo SmithKline's Paxil to a high of 69 percent for Bristol-Myers-Squibb's Serzone.
Turner said that this exaggeration of a drug's effectiveness can lead doctors to prescribe it in borderline cases where it might not be appropriate.
"Selective publication can lead doctors to make inappropriate prescribing decisions that may not be in the best interest of their patients and, thus, the public health," the researchers wrote.
The researchers said that the publication bias did not necessarily arise from drug companies actively concealing data. One explanation might be that researchers find negative results uninteresting, and do not go to the effort of writing them up.
"There's an expectation that if you get a positive result, that's what you're supposed to do, and if you get a negative result you have failed," Turner said. "The first impulse is to say, 'I was wrong. Maybe I should move on to something more interesting.'"
The bias could just as easily come from medical journals being more interested in studies with positive results, Turner said, and not from the researchers at all.
Newsweek columnist Sharon Begley expressed skepticism with this view.
"I think he's being too kind," Begley said. "With the proliferation of journals, virtually anything can get published somewhere - maybe not in the New England Journal of Medicine, but in some third-tier rag, which would still count as 'published.'"
Regardless of the reasons behind it, it is widely acknowledged that publication bias has far-reaching ramifications. It skews the results of meta-analyses, in which researchers compile the results of many published studies to get a better picture of how effective a drug or other therapy is. In extreme cases, it can create a totally false impression: Because studies are typically conducted within a 5 percent confidence interval, it is expected that one in 20 of those studies will show a false result simply due to random variation. If only that study is published and the 19 studies showing no results are never seen, this conveys the opposite impression of what the research actually found.
While the current study is the most thorough to date examining publication bias in the drug industry, health professionals have long known that this bias is a problem. In 2004, the state of New York sued Glaxo SmithKline for intentionally concealing the results of studies on Paxil in order to make it appear that the drug was more effective on children and adolescents. The company also sought to conceal evidence of dangerous side effects, the lawsuit alleged, such as an increased incidence of suicidal tendencies.
While that lawsuit was eventually settled, at least 12 jury trials are scheduled for 2008 that accuse Glaxo SmithKline of hiding suicidal side effects in youths.
As part of the 2004 settlement, Glaxo SmithKline agreed to post the results of all its drug trials on the Internet, and other major companies followed suit. In response to the New England Journal of Medicine study, spokespeople for several drug companies pointed to this practice as evidence that the system has been reformed.
But Turner says that posting results online is not the same as publishing them in the medical literature. He doesn't know a single doctor, he said, who regularly consults the companies' online databases.
"We are taught that the medical literature is the Holy Grail," he said.
About the author: Mike Adams is a natural health researcher and author with a mission to teach personal and planetary health to the public He is a prolific writer and has published thousands of articles, interviews, reports and consumer guides, reaching millions of readers with information that is saving lives and improving personal health around the world. Adams is an independent journalist with strong ethics who does not get paid to write articles about any product or company. In 2007, Adams launched EcoLEDs, a maker of energy efficient LED lights that greatly reduce CO2 emissions. He also founded an environmentally-friendly online retailer called BetterLifeGoods.com that uses retail profits to help support consumer advocacy programs. He's also the founder and CEO of a well known email mail merge software developer whose software, 'Email Marketing Director,' currently runs the NaturalNews email subscriptions. Adams also serves as the executive director of the Consumer Wellness Center, a non-profit consumer protection group, and regularly pursues cycling, nature photography, Capoeira and Pilates. Known by his callsign, the 'Health Ranger,' Adams posts his missions statements, health statistics and health photos at www.HealthRanger.org
 Get articles like this delivered to you FREE in our popular email newsletter
|
 |
This new Omega-3 oil makes fish oil obsoleteHave you heard about green-lipped mussel oil and its amazing pain relief properties? See the comparison with fish oils.
Click here to find out more
This is the revolutionary omega-3 oil you've been hearing about. Click the link above to find out more.
|
The Health Ranger reveals financial protection strategies for tough timesThis eight-CD audio seminar by the Health Ranger reveals hard-core financial protection strategies for surviving the next wave of the global financial crisis.
Click here to protect yourself now
"Guaranteed to deliver the most powerful financial protection advice you've ever seen or your money back!" - Mike Adams, the Health Ranger
|
Recommended Products Related to This Article*:Free download: Selling Sickness (summary)
Read the best book on disease mongering
for learning the truth about Big Pharma
Revealed: Natural Health Solutions (free)
Free summary of book by Mike Adams
for learning censored natural health remedies
Additional Products of Interest to AllBreville Juice Fountain Elite 800JEXL☯
Simply the best juicer in the world
for fast, easy juicing
Paraliminal Audio Courses☯
Powerful mind-enhancing audio therapy
for reprogramming your mind for a new future
How to Halt Diabetes in 25 Days☯
Health Ranger guide to reversing diabetes
for reversing type-2 diabetes
Boku Superfood
High-potency superfood powder
for preventing numerous diseases
Preparedness Tools Natural News Bundle☯
For preparedness and safety: 60% off
for preparing for natural disasters
Katadyn Exstream XR Water Purifier☯
#1 personal water purifier
for clean, pristine water in seconds
Healing Cancer From the Inside Out (DVD)
Amazing, eye-opening cancer documentary
for anyone wanting to know the truth on cancer
Zeitgeist: Addendum - Must-See Movie
A shocking documentary about money
for people who wan to know the real truth
The Genie In Your Genes by Dawson Church
A free, downloadable summary of this book
for learning about the biology of intention
Spirulina Pacifica
Pure, pristine spirulina superfood
for cancer prevention, alkalizing, immune func
The Biology of Belief by Bruce Lipton
A free download of Biology of Belief
for learning about the mind-biology connection
Living Fuel SuperBerry Ultimate
Delicious superfood meal powder
for disease prevention, antioxidant boost
The Weiss Method for Heart Disease☯
How to reverse heart disease naturally
for heart disease, high cholesterol
Appetite for Profit (free download)
Free download summary of this top book
for discovering the truth about food companies
Hair Soap
A pure, simple and chemical-free shampoo
for washing hair without chemicals
Exposed! The Toxic Chemistry of Products
Free summary of this shocking book
for learning the truth about toxic products
Aloe Vera 100
Pure, dried 100% aloe vera gel flakes
for sludge blood, IBS, Crohn's disease
Katadyn MicroPur Water Purifier Tablets☯
The best water purification tablets
for purifying almost any water source
Vitamineral Green from Healthforce
Nutrient-dense superfood powder
for disease prevention, body alkalizing & more
Fucoxanthin with PinnoThin
Natural appetite suppressant
for obesity, overweight, overeating
Zyflamend
Powerful anti-inflammatory herbal formula
for arthritis, joint pain, inflammation
Nascent Iodine
Miraculous nascent iodine solution
for thyroid function, Alzheimer's, brain func.
Blood Support
Halts growth of cancer tumors
for breast cancer and all cancers
Amaz-a-Power
Amazing wild berry tincture from Peru
for eye & brain protection, cancer prevention
P-73 Oreganol
Potent source of wildcrafted oregano oil
for parasites, heart disease, immune func.
Ocean Minerals Pure Magnesium Oil
#1 product for magnesium therapy
for back pain, heart health, muscle health
MGC-5 Mushroom Extracts
Potent extracts of medicinal mushrooms
for reversing cancer, boosting immune function
Better Than Roasted - Macadamia Nuts☯
The most delicious raw nut spread ever
for heart health, circulatory health
* Products do NOT pay to be listed here. These are genuine, independent recommendations by the Health Ranger
☯ Products with this symbol are sold by NaturalNews or its affiliates and earn revenues for NaturalNews
|
|
Printable Version
Email this article to a friend
Share this article on: 
