What makes us different? Read our Declaration of Journalistic Independence Home | About Natural News | Contact Us | Write for Natural News
Search our 25,000 free articles and special reports
medical ethics

Protestors call for investigation into growth-stunting procedure for mentally disabled girl

Wednesday, January 17, 2007 by: Ben Kage | Key concepts: medical ethics, forced sterilization and disabled rights

Want stories like this e-mailed to you? Click here for free email alerts

Email this article to a friend Printable Version

Is the FDA a threat to your health?

Fight for Your Health, Exposing the FDA's betrayal of America by Byron Richards.

"This book should be read by every American."
- Mike Adams, editor, NaturalNews.com

Learn the uncensored truth about:

  • The corruption of top FDA officials
  • Why the FDA is a danger to public safety
  • How drug companies conspire with the FDA to discredit alternatives
  • How the FDA uses scientific fraud and censorship to fool the public
  • How we can WIN the war on health freedom and take back our future!
Receive two free gifts when you order from us, including Mike Adams' "Top Ten Ways to Protect Your Health Freedom" checklist.

Click here to learn more

(NaturalNews) Protestors have demanded that state and federal authorities investigate possible rights violations in the case of the brain-damaged Seattle girl known only as Ashley, who underwent a growth-stunting medical procedure at the behest of her parents in order to make care of the 12-year-old girl easier as she got older.

"It is unethical and unacceptable to perform intrusive and invasive medical procedures on a person or child with a disability simply to make the person easier to care for," said Steven Taylor, director of Syracuse University's Center on Human Policy. A hospital institutional review board should have been consulted before what amounted to a medical experiment was authorized, says Taylor.

According to Kristina Borror, a director for the federal Office for Human Research Protections -- where many complaints about Ashley's treatment have been registered -- the office does not consider the 2004 procedure to be a research case, and the situation is therefore outside of its power. Dr. Richard Molteni, medical director of the Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center in Seattle where the procedure was performed, said that Ashley's case was not experimental and therefore did not require consultation with an institutional review board.

Ashley was rendered immobile, unable to feed herself, and mentally 3 months old by a severe brain disorder known as a static encephalopathy. In order to keep her from being too heavy to move and care for, Ashley's as-yet-unidentified parents requested a procedure that involved the purposeful stunting of her growth through a hysterectomy, the removal of her breast buds, and a regimen of estrogen treatments. Doctors say that Ashley is unlikely to grow much beyond her current 4-foot-5 frame, if at all. They theorize she would have reached a height close to 5-foot-5 if she had not undergone the procedure. The doctors also say the treatments will prevent Ashley from ever having to deal with menstruation or its symptoms, and significantly reduce her chances of breast cancer, which her parents report runs in the family.

The case has drawn attention from critics both inside and outside the United States ever since her parents detailed the treatment in an online blog last week. Feminist groups and disabled-rights groups are calling for the American Medical Association's ethics committee to investigate Ashley's case, and although Washington has no laws against forced sterilization, the state attorney general's office has said a complaint from a New Jersey disabled-rights activist is currently being assessed.

Protestors have also demanded that the AMA officially condemn the procedure, as Ashley's case was first published in the association's Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, although the magazine has its own independent editorial board. The AMA basically endorsed the treatment by authorizing publication of the report, says Amber Smock of Feminist Response in Disability Activism, but journal editor Dr. Frederick Rivara said the report was published in the hopes that it would cause this very debate in the scientific community.

According to Molteni, the decision to authorize the procedure was "thoroughly reviewed by a wide range of medical and surgical specialists, including neurologists, development specialists and ethicists," and the hospital is convinced the procedure was in Ashley's best interests.

###

Related Articles

Movie Review: The Island starring Ewan McGregor explores timely theme of corporate exploitation of human beings

Following revelation that new cholesterol advice came from board members who profit from statin drug makers, medical leaders see no conflict of interest

Unconscious surgical patients unknowingly practiced on by med school students

Surgeons "maimed" brain damaged child to "convenience" caregivers, health advocate charges

Physicians and bribery: a closer look at this common medical industry practice

Additional Resources:

medical ethics
forced sterilization
disabled rights

Take Action: Support NaturalNews.com

Email this article to a friend

Share this article on: NewsVine | digg | del.icio.us

Permalink to this article: http://www.NaturalNews.com/021440.html

Reprinting this article: Non-commercial OK, cite NaturalNews.com with clickable link.

Receive our Natural Health Newsletter for FREE

Subscribe now (it's free!) to win. We randomly choose a subscriber each month to send $100 in eco-home products or a RealGoods.com gift certificate (our choice). Plus, you'll receive FREE news, articles and action alerts from NaturalNews.com editors and join over 800,000 monthly readers who report extraordinary health improvements after becoming a subscriber!
  • Receive breaking news alerts on natural health solutions, renewable energy, the environment, global warming and more.
  • Receive a free instant download of our $29 Secret Sources guide that reveals top sources for little-known health and diet solutions.
Your Email Address:
Free Subscription Code:
Enter the numbers you see:
100% free of charge. Unsubscribe anytime.
Absolutely no spam. We respect your email privacy.

Recommended Special Report:

Seven Words that can Change the World
by Joseph R. Simonetta

Read this special report now...

"Seven Words That Can Change the World reveals the astonishing, simple truths that have the power to forever transform our world for the better while freeing our minds from the enslavement of limiting beliefs. This is not a text for the simple-minded; it is a guiding philosophy for the mindful, intelligent few who are wise enough to seek out -- and recognize -- the higher simplicities of truly purposeful living." - Mike Adams, the Health Ranger, editor of NaturalNews.com

More on NaturalNews.com:

Streaming Health Ranger Videos
CounterThink Cartoons
FREE Special Reports
Podcasts

Also Posted Today

Coccinia Indica Herb Lowers Blood Sugar Levels by 20 Percent in Type 2 Diabetics

Large Scale Study Finds Vitamin B6 Deficiency Common in the U.S.

Therapeutic Healing Vest for Children With Autism, ADHD, Anxiety

Registered Dietitian Jill Fleming Gives Advice on Staying Healthy

Cholesterol Disease Mongering Reaches New Low with Statin Drug Push For 8-Year-Olds

Beat Disease With Juice Feasting!

NEW 6-CD audio set reveals amazing new protocol for reversing cancer, diabetes, obesity, heart disease and more. Click to learn more.

Own Health Ranger Report Podcasts on Audio CD

Own the first 8 Health Ranger Report audio programs on 6 CDs. Covers weight loss, ADHD, vaccinations, processed meats, bone health and more. Click to learn more.

Featured Videos

Short clip on Aspartame
A short clip on aspartame from the documentary All Jacked Up.
Click here to view now...

Exclusive video on Aspartame
The dangers of aspartame! Exclusive interview footage from Cori Brackett of Sweet Remedy.
Click here to view now...

Exclusive Footage from All Jacked Up!
See interview footage featuring the Health Ranger in the upcoming junk food film, All Jacked Up.
Click here to view now...

Drug Ad Parody
See the Health Ranger's satire parody of Merck's cholesterol drug ad.
Click here to view now...

Free Health Reports!

Amazon Herb Company review
The pH Nutrition Guide to Acid / Alkaline Balance
Pet Food Ingredients Revealed! (shocking)
Medicine From Fish
The Water Cure
The Healing Power of Sunlight and Vitamin D

Featured CounterThink Cartoons

Adderall vs. Meth


Feeding the young


HPV Vaccine Texas Tyranny


Health Product Companies We Recommend

Read recommendations on supplement companies, health food manufacturers and personal care product makers that you can trust. Our 100% independent review list tells you who to trust and who to avoid in the natural health industry. Click to read.
This site is part of the Natural News Network © 2008 All Rights Reserved. Privacy | Terms All content posted on this site is commentary or opinion and is protected under Free Speech. Truth Publishing International, LTD. is not responsible for content written by contributing authors. Truth Publishing sells no health or nutritional products and earns no money from health product manufacturers or promoters. The information on this site is provided for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for professional advice of any kind. Truth Publishing assumes no responsibility for the use or misuse of this material. Your use of this website indicates your agreement to these terms and those published here. All trademarks, registered trademarks and servicemarks mentioned on this site are the property of their respective owners.